Here’s a super easy recipe for eggnog that we tried for the first time this year. Previously, we waited expectantly for the first carton to appear on the grocery store shelves then promptly took it home and cut it by half with milk because it was so disgustingly thick. This is MUCH better. I will never buy store-made again. Well, I probably will because I said I “never” would and of course, as soon as you say you “never will” anything then it happens. Anyway…. here’s the recipe (in bold) the rest is just noise.
Super, Easy Eggnog
*6 eggs (We used very fresh, organic eggs. I kind of wished we still had our own chickens because then I could have been absolutely sure about where those eggs had been. Though I suppose anything that comes out of an animals backside underside? is probably a little suspect regardless of who that animal belongs to. Anyway, I say all that because this is a no cook recipe which means raw eggs in and raw eggs out so, you know, be careful about your egg choice.)
*1 cup sugar (Will was the chef for this one so since it said sugar he used sugar. I probably would have replaced this with some agave nectar to taste…. but that’s just me.)
*1 tsp vanilla (For heaven’s sake please use the real stuff. Why do you even have that bottle of imitation in your cupboard?)
*1/4 tsp nutmeg (I’m not even going to suggest you grate this fresh because I know you won’t…. okay, okay, I didn’t either.)
*2 cups milk (We used organic, whole milk but I’m going to try again after the first of the year with fresh raw milk because I finally found someone local who will sell us some.)
*2 cups heavy whipping cream (That ingredient alone should convince you this is going to be good.)
*1/4 cup dark rum (Okay, maybe it was that ingredient that convinced you. To be truthful, the original recipe called for 3/4 cup rum and 3/4 cup brandy. We scaled it back to just the rum on our first try and then back further still so the alcohol wouldn’t overpower the other flavors.)
For best results, chill everything before you start. Beat the eggs until they are frothy then beat in the sugar, vanilla, and nutmeg. Slowly stir in the rum, cream and milk. Chill your completed eggnog again and serve very cold with nutmeg sprinkled on top.
Let me know if you try this!